Page 69 - Microsoft Word - miniz-digest-80-85.docx
P. 69
aroma over time, but pinning down the change to particular components is difficult because they all change at
the same time,' he says.
Perhaps the most difficult quality of scotch to define and relate to chemistry is 'smoothness'. What makes
people describe one malt as 'smooth' or 'mellow', and another as 'harsh' appears to be more of a physical than
a chemical characteristic. A theory favoured by Nishimura and his colleagues is that the spirit matures,
hydrogen bonds form between the alcohol and the water molecules, so that they form stable clusters. Piggott
and Conner aim to repeat the Japanese work and extend it, using both whiskies and model solutions, by
measuring energy changes caused by hydrogen bonding and identifying the structures that form between
molecules.
They are particularly interested in tracking the fate of compounds containing sulphur and nitrogen because their
contribution to the flavour decreases steadily as the new spirit is transformed into a mature Scotch. Wood
components appear to be closely linked with this decrease. Conner thinks that as the concentration of oak
extracts increase, so does the solubility of other components such as hexadecanol and tetradecanol - long
chain alcohols with at least 14 carbons - and esters of organic acids with between 10 and 18 carbons. It seems
likely that when the concentration of wood components, especially phenols, reaches a certain level, the alcohols
and esters begin to form loose groups, perhaps with the sulphur and nitrogen-containing hydrocarbons. This
makes them less free to move in the liquid and therefore less available for evaporation into the 'headspace'
above the liquid, where they can contribute to the aroma.
Researchers in countries not noted for their whisky are equally keen to discover the secrets of Scotch. Lalli
Nykanen heads the analytical department of the research laboratories of Alko, the Finnish state alcohol
company, and his team of researchers has spent years trying to find out what makes whisky - Canadian,
American and Scotch - the way it is. So far they have pinpointed some 400 different flavour components in
whisky, mainly fatty acids, esters, alcohols and aldehydes. But even after a decade they have not managed to
track down a basic chemical recipe common to the best brands. 'It's very difficult to say what the main
components of the flavour are,' says Nykanen. 'Whisky contains many fusel (long chain) alcohols but aldehydes
are also very important to the flavour, even though they are present in much smaller quantities. Almost all fatty
acids and fatty acid esters from acetic to stearic occur in whisky. Esters of fatty acids are very volatile, so they
give the whisky a strong flavour.'
In one experiment, Nykanen and his colleagues pickled oak chips in alcohol to mimic the maturation process.
The alcohol freed 44 different varieties of acids, lactones and esters from the oak. 'We have found that there are
600 to 800 compounds in whisky, but how they are related and how they affect the flavour is not clear,' says
Nykanen. 'You smell and taste whisky using your nose and your mouth, but combining sensory tests with
chemicals analysis is very difficult. We have tried using statistical methods and computers, but it's not easy. I
think it will be 5 or 10 years before we can say we know what makes the flavour.'
Alko has been producing two brands of whisky for the past 10 years, based on the results of their research. In
the search for excellence, the company imports brewer's and distiller's yeasts from several countries, including
Scotland. There is good evidence that Alko has not yet succeeded in developing a whisky to rival Scotch,
however: Nykanen prefers to drink The Glenlivet, a single Highland malt that matures for a leisurely 12 years.
In time, chemists will eventually analyse and identify all the flavours in the distillate. Using the latest techniques,
combining gas chromatography and mass spectrometry, they can detect compounds present at the parts per
billion level. One problem with the most sensitive method is that what the chemists are measuring is not
precisely the same thing that the blenders are nosing - the headspace of vapours above a standard measure of
whisky in a standard, tulip-shaped glass. The nearest they get is probably to take a syringe full of vapours from
above a sample of whisky. Even then, some of the heavier compounds may not always be present in the vapour
in sufficient quantities to be detected.
So far, not even chemists working in the heart of Scotland have managed to find the right mix of molecules in
the right proportions. It seems that Scotch will be baffling chemists for some years yet. 'The way it's made is an
art,' argues Conner. 'You can't do without the blenders. What the analytical chemists should be able to do is
provide some predictions of how a whisky will mature and which barrel to use, so the whisky from a particular
distillery is consistent. But you couldn't produce a whisky in a test tube and compare it with one that has been
maturing for 8 years. Anyway, it wouldn't be Scotch.' After all, perhaps 15 years isn't too long to wait for a good
malt.
o
o
t
e
t
w
o
w
r
r
h
h
i
s
i
e
T
T
d
i
e
d
i
N N
Noidea Whowrote Thiss
o
o
e
h
W
o
h
W
a
a
Noidea Whowrote This

