Page 68 - Microsoft Word - miniz-digest-80-85.docx
P. 68
In the early 1980s, George Reazin and his colleagues at the whisky manufacturer Joseph Seagram of
Louisville, Kentucky tried to work out what goes on in a cask of maturing whisky. They studied American whisky
('whiskey'), but their results are just as valid for Scotch because the same basic processes apply to the
maturation of both. They found that there were some physical effects: the concentration of the whisky when it
enters the cask affects the levels of some flavour molecules, while the temperature at which the cask is stored
affected how quickly the molecules form. Traditionally, malt whisky begins maturation at about 63 per cent
alcohol and Scotland's climate is allowed maximum influence over casks stored in unregulated warehouses.
As for the chemistry, Reazin and his colleagues concluded that some of the final flavours come from chemical
reactions that take place between molecules already in the distillate, while some aromatic compounds, such as
syringaldehyde and vanillin - the origin of sweet, 'woody' aromas - come from the breakdown of the cask. This
was a challenge. Although chemists know the structure of cellulose, they know much less about the other
compounds in wood, such as hemicelluloses and lignin.
Lignin is the stuff that makes trees 'woody'. It seems to be a random polymer that binds to hemicellulose in the
plant cell walls, forming a resin that surrounds the cellulose fibres which give the cell wall its structural strength.
The polymer is made up of three monomers, each containing a benzene ring with side chains containing carbon
atoms joined by double bonds. The monomers can be linked in various ways: side chain to ring, ring to ring and
side chain to side chain. Bonds between side chains are the easiest to break and so these can be attacked by
ethyl alcohol and water in a process called hydrolysis. It seems likely that during maturation, the young whisky
extracts wood components from the cask in this way.
Russian chemists were the first to realise that the molecules produced by the breakdown of lignin were
important to maturation when, during the 1950s, they identified the aromatic aldehydes syringaldehyde and
vanillin in brandy. Later, other researchers turned their attention to whiskies. In 1983, Kiichi Nishimura and his
colleagues from the Suntory company in Osaka worked out in more detail how compounds related to lignin
become part of mature whisky.
Despite their efforts, the breakdown of lignin is still not entirely understood. It is thought to give rise to molecules
such as coniferyl alcohol, sinapaldehyde and vanillic acid, precursors of related molecules such as
syringaldehyde and vanillin that are known to contribute to flavour. With funding from the Agricultural and Food
Research Council and the Scotch whisky industry, John Piggott, Alistair Paterson and John Conner from the
University of Strathclyde have completed a three-year study of how molecules formed from the breakdown of
lignin and tannin from cask wood affect whisky maturation. They studied one type of breakdown product,
aromatic acids and phenols, to find out how much is extracted from the cask wood, and exactly where in the
cask the lignin breaks down.
During maturation, the alcohol and water penetrate the entire depth of cask wood. The Strathclyde team
discovered that as the whisky matures, the inner faces of the cask quickly become devoid of phenols and easily
degradable lignin. As the cask ages, these molecules are found in the highest concentrations deeper inside the
wood.
Maturation limits the life of any cask. Less than 4 per cent of the total lignin in an oak cask can be broken down
easily by the spirit it contains. In practice, most casks contain whisky for 50 years or more, until the aroma of
whisky gives telltale signs that all the easily degradable lignin has been used up. From this point onwards the
casks no longer produce a good maturation; the oak contributes little to the final taste and aroma. 'The spirit that
comes out of the barrel smells worse than when it was put it,' says Conner. 'You start to get some very peculiar
flavours.'
In 1974, many of the largest whisky manufacturers in Scotland formed a consortium to study ways of improving
whisky and its methods of production. Most of the research done at Pentlands Scotch Whisky Research
Institute near Edinburgh remains firmly under wraps, but the consortium is interested in developing new strains
of yeast and in analysing maturation. Chemists at Strathclyde and Pentlands have now identified many of the
chemical changes that go on during maturation. For example, flavours associated with sulphur-based
compounds and certain aldehydes decrease, whereas there is an increase in flavours associated with vanillin
and wood components as these are extracted. Chemists can identify many of the compounds - the problem is
tying them into particular flavours. Some molecules, such as those containing sulphur and nitrogen, are present
only in minute quantities, parts per billion, but you can smell them nevertheless. Other molecules less crucial to
the flavour may be present in much larger quantities.
Timing is important for many of the reactions. The whisky industry would like to speed up the maturation
process - manufacturers lose a costly 2 per cent per year in evaporation through the casks, which is officially
recognised by the Customs & Excise in Scotland. Conner believes this is impossible, because no one can
predict how speeding up one reaction will affect the others. 'You can follow the changes that take place in

