Page 67 - Microsoft Word - miniz-digest-80-85.docx
P. 67
Mysteries of the malt
Whisky drinkers are true romantics. They believe that making whisky is a mysterious and wonderful art, its
flavour the result of subtle differences between Highland or Lowland air and water, or the effect of sea salt,
heather or peat. You can almost hear chemists darkly muttering 'hocus-pocus'. But sceptics should beware:
despite the predominance of alcohol and water, demystifying the molecules in a bottle of Scotch is trickier than
it sounds.
Thirty years ago, chemists intent on discovering the secrets of Scotch would have concentrated their efforts on
long-chain alcohols produced during fermentation. During the past decade, however, advances in analytical
techniques have revealed that Scotch contains minute quantities of as many as 500 different molecules. Now it
is beginning to look as though the unique flavour of whisky depends less on the influence of one or two
dominant compounds than on an extremely complex series of chemical reactions, going on at different rates
and various times. Not all the 500 molecules produced in these reactions may be important, but finding out
where they come from and how they fit into the chemistry is essential before we can understand the flavour of
whisky. Although fermentation matters, the real key seems to lie in the final step of the whisky-making process
when many of these chemical reactions take place. What happens at this last stage - maturation - remains a
puzzle.
Malt whiskies, renowned for their distinctive flavours, are traditionally produced in a copper 'pot still'. While
chemists look for answers in the various stages of this process, according to traditional practice the last word in
the individuality of a whisky belongs to the blender. Whisky manufacturers rely on skilful blenders with a nose
for whisky, often acquired through long years of apprenticeship in the trade. Their job is to blend together spirit
from different casks - each of a different colour, aroma and flavour - so that each batch is consistent with the
last. Even single malts are blends of whiskies from different casks. A good blender, helped by a tasting panel of
another half-dozen people, can 'nose' 2000 samples a week, and has no fear of being replaced by chemical
technology. Using gas-liquid chromatography, a sensitive technique familiar to analytical chemists, it would be
possible to analyse the content of only 140 samples a week, working round the clock. Even then, such an
analysis would be a poor guide to flavour. Blenders use a rich and detailed vocabulary to describe the various
aromas of spirits from different distillations, from rancid to rubbery and peaty to phenolic, and the 'formula' for a
particular blend is a closely guarded secret within each distillery.
So how does a whisky acquire its distinctive flavour? Both blenders and chemists already have some clues.
They know that using different types of barley has a strong effect, for example. And most people can recognise
a peated malt, produced from barley that has had peat smoke blown through it, a relic of the days when barley
was dried over fires fuelled by peat or heather. Peat smoke contains organic ring compounds that have double
carbon-carbon bonds. Chemists call all kinds of carbon-based rings 'aromatic', but the ones found in peat
smoke have a distinctive aroma and they give the whisky a pungent flavour. Other flavours derive from the
distillation process itself. At this point the type of yeast is important, and distillers often add carefully selected
varieties of spent brewer's yeast to give particular flavours. Even the shape of the still is crucial; complex
chemical reactions take place on its surface, and different shapes will select and condense different
compounds. Especially important during distillation is the breakdown of sulphur-containing hydrocarbons such
as dimethyl sulphide. Trace amounts of copper from the still probably catalyse this reaction, which may explain
why malt whisky is traditionally distilled in copper, not glass.
When Scots first distilled whisky, they would have drunk the new spirit without waiting for it to mature. But this
meant that whisky making had to be an activity for winter, just after the barley harvest and at a time when there
were adequate supplies of water. Maturation in oak casks probably evolved as a form of storage, but today
newly distilled spirit is considered undrinkable. Blenders know it as a liquid with a rather unpleasantly sharp,
pungent aroma. Chemists have a good idea what it contains, in addition to ethanol and water: phenols, from
malt and peak smoke, along with esters, lactones, aldehydes and some compounds that contain sulphur and
nitrogen. These molecules provide the basic flavour, but by law the spirit is not Scotch whisky until it has been
left to mature in an oak cask for at least three years.
Chemists began to study the changes that take place in maturing whiskies in the early years of last century.
They still have a long way to go. All they can say for sure is that a decade or so is long enough for the slowest
moving alcohol to be transformed into something more interesting. It is a complex and lengthy process,
involving many different reactions. Oxygen diffuses into the cask, mixing with the vapours already present in the
'headspace' above the new spirit, and ethanol and water evaporate out. In the liquid itself, some alcohols are
oxidised to aldehydes, and aldehydes to acids; other alcohols react with acids to give esters, or with aldehydes
to form acetals. As many as 17 years later, the whisky is pronounced mature.

